Pi Pizzeria was founded with the intention of preserving traditional, classic Neapolitan recipes while adding our own unique twist to create authentically “Pi Pizza.” In Naples, every pizzeria is slightly different – each adding its own flourish of tradition and personality. Similarly, Pi Pizzeria achieves authenticity, making it authentically Italian.

Our humble beginnings began in 2001 in the back of a wine and cheese shop on Nantucket Island. From there, Evan Marley’s dream of owning his own pizzeria became a reality in 2006. Pi Pizzeria, located at 11 West Creek Road, Nantucket, serves authentic wood-fired, thin-crust Neapolitan pizza and offers classic Italian-American cuisine.

We have created a warm, intimate feel in our dining room, which is filled with the tantalizing aroma of hot pizza coming from our wood-burning oven and the mouth-watering scent of fresh Roma tomato sauce gently simmering on the stove.

Pi Pizzeria’s lively Bar is Italian-inspired with specialty drinks, liquor, beer, and a superb Italian wine list. Our Bartenders are experienced cocktailians with a passion for the art of mixology. Our bar fills up as quickly as our dining room and serves our entire menu.